46°
Mostly cloudy
THU
 75°
 48°
FRI
 72°
 47°
SAT
 71°
 45°
SUN
 70°
 43°
MON
 75°
 42°

PD Editorial: Blowing noise
Sebastopol should work with gardeners before banning leaf-blowers

  • Sebastopol council members are discussing whether to ban gas-powered leaf blowers. (CHRISTOPHER CHUNG / The Press Democrat, 2005)

Will somebody please explain what logical purpose a leaf blower affords its user other than blasting the morning air waves, rattling the brain cells of its victims ... Letter writer from Santa Rosa, Aug. 13

The leaf blower is a modern convenience that serves a very useful purpose. You can go ahead and try to take it away. Youll have to pry it out of my cold dead hands. Letter writer from Sebastopol, Aug. 17

If its autumn, it must be time to argue about leaf blowers.

But the city of Sebastopol is taking the debate one step further this year. The City Council is considering whether Sebastopol should become the first community in Sonoma County to ban the machines outright.

City Councilman Guy Wilson asked for the issue to be put on the councils agenda last week in response to complaints from Sebastopol residents. He wants the city to explore going the route of communities such as Mill Valley, Berkeley and Palo Alto, which have bans on gasoline-powered leafblowers.

Thankfully, he and others on the City Council dont appear to be in a rush to approve an outright ban anytime soon.

While its hard to justify the noise generated by these contraptions particularly to those who work nights or are trying to put their children down for a nap a ban would likely generate more ill will, and more unintended consequences, than necessary.

For example, as Public Works Director Richard Emig told the council last week, city workers themselves use gas-powered leaf-blowers, three of them to be exact, to clear walkways and parking lots of leaves. The city would need to evaluate the financial impacts of requiring these workers to shift to rakes or some less-obnoxious equipment.

In addition, if its strictly a noise issue, the City Council needs to figure out how it would justify banning leaf-blowers but not power lawn mowers or other loud equipment.

More important, the city should hear more from landscapers, gardeners and others who depend on leafblowers for their livelihood. Taking away such a tool in this down economy could be a back-breaker for some of them.

Instead of enacting a ban, the City Council would be better off appointing a committee of local gardening professionals to work with staff in the development of guidelines for the safe and sane use of leafblowers.

Right now, the city doesnt even limit their hours of operation. That sounds like a good place to start.

© The Press Democrat |  Terms of Service |  Privacy Policy |  Jobs With Us |  RSS |  Advertising |  Sonoma Media Investments |  Place an Ad
Switch to our Mobile View